| 285 | 164 | Nicholas | Siciliano | M | 12 | 28 | M1119 | Yonkers | NY | 1:03:28.0 | 15:52 | |
| 325 | 165 | Reece | Larkin | M | 12 | 29 | M1119 | Tuckahoe | NY | 1:03:28.3 | 15:53 | Cormac Fahy's Annunciation classmates |
| 214 | 166 | Fiona | Fahy | F | 47 | 3 | F4049 | Yonkers | NY | 1:08:30.8 | 17:08 | Engine 75 / Ladder 33 / Battalion 19 |
| 354 | 1 | Jeff | Pellis | M | 46 | 1 | M4049 | New York | NY | 24:05.5 | 6:02 | L-25 |
| 234 | 2 | Vincent | Improta | M | 33 | 1 | M3039 | Staten Island | NY | 24:08.3 | 6:03 | Ladder 114 |
| 295 | 3 | Luke | Wagner | M | 28 | 1 | M2029 | Brooklyn | NY | 25:24.1 | 6:22 | E28/L11 |
| 301 | 4 | Christopher | Wilson | M | 30 | 2 | M3039 | New York | NY | 26:23.6 | 6:36 | Engine 47 |
| 336 | 5 | Garrett | Langdon | M | 38 | 3 | M3039 | Ridgewood | NY | 26:23.9 | 6:36 | L-127 |
| 257 | 6 | Sean | McLiverty | M | 36 | 4 | M3039 | Fishkill | NY | 26:31.5 | 6:38 | Ladder 52 |
| 258 | 7 | Christopher | McSorle | M | 31 | 5 | M3039 | Manhattan | NY | 27:07.9 | 6:47 | L38 |
| 221 | 8 | Patrick | Fiffe | M | 36 | 6 | M3039 | East Rockaway | NY | 27:21.7 | 6:51 | Animal House |
| 260 | 9 | Kieran | Moran | M | 29 | 2 | M2029 | Bronx | NY | 27:26.1 | 6:52 | Engine 83 |
| 209 | 10 | Armando | Ellis | M | 38 | 7 | M3039 | New York | NY | 27:27.7 | 6:52 | FDNY |
| 322 | 11 | Timothy | Burke | M | 33 | 8 | M3039 | Bronx | NY | 27:32.4 | 6:54 | NYPD Gaelic Football |
| 252 | 12 | Steven | Marsalese | M | 20 | 3 | M2029 | Bronx | NY | 27:46.7 | 6:57 | |
| 192 | 13 | Gregory | Cirincione | M | 32 | 9 | M3039 | Brooklyn | NY | 27:47.4 | 6:57 | Engine 28 Ladder 11 |
| 174 | 14 | Nicholas | Bernstein | M | 25 | 4 | M2029 | Staten Island | NY | 27:58.3 | 7:00 | Engine 35 Ladder 14 Battalion 12 |
| 352 | 15 | Sebastian | Curti | M | 18 | 1 | M1119 | Flushing | NY | 28:02.1 | 7:01 | M-1 |
| 230 | 16 | Matthew | Guttilla | M | 38 | 10 | M3039 | Sunnyside | NY | 28:14.2 | 7:04 | L55 |
| 337 | 17 | Brian | Clarke | M | 34 | 11 | M3039 | Sayville | NY | 28:27.1 | 7:07 | Ladder 127 |
| 343 | 18 | Jeffrey | Espreo | M | 34 | 12 | M3039 | Mohegan Lake | NY | 28:58.6 | 7:15 | L52 |
| 171 | 19 | Dylan | Bell | M | 32 | 13 | M3039 | Peekskill | NY | 29:08.2 | 7:18 | Animal house E-75 |
| 220 | 20 | Artem | Feldman | M | 37 | 14 | M3039 | Bronx | NY | 29:20.0 | 7:20 | L116 |
| 274 | 21 | Rawley | Rosa | M | 39 | 15 | M3039 | Bronx | NY | 29:33.5 | 7:24 | Engine 52 |
| 350 | 22 | Lenwill | Burmester | M | 18 | 2 | M1119 | Whitestone | NY | 30:01.9 | 7:31 | M-1 |
| 355 | 23 | Michael | Decker | M | 38 | 16 | M3039 | White Plains | NY | 30:25.8 | 7:37 | E62/L32 |
| 176 | 24 | Zachary | Boland | M | 31 | 17 | M3039 | Astoria | NY | 30:27.2 | 7:37 | Engine75 |
| 291 | 25 | Matthew | Trimmer | M | 26 | 5 | M2029 | Staten Island | NY | 30:28.9 | 7:38 | Engine 28/ Ladder 11 |
| 200 | 26 | David | Deleon-Harris | M | 37 | 18 | M3039 | Bronx | NY | 30:31.9 | 7:38 | Engine 75 |
| 269 | 27 | Francisco | Perez | M | 35 | 19 | M3039 | New York | NY | 30:36.4 | 7:40 | TL014 |
| 369 | 28 | Candido | Nunez | M | 47 | 2 | M4049 | Bronx | NY | 30:42.5 | 7:41 | |
| 360 | 29 | Michael | Triolo | M | 39 | 20 | M3039 | Bronxbronx | NY | 30:45.9 | 7:42 | L14 |
| 245 | 30 | Diane | Kenna | F | 58 | 1 | F5059 | New York | NY | 30:59.2 | 7:45 | |
| 328 | 31 | Kevin | Oconnor | M | 39 | 21 | M3039 | Carmel | NY | 31:03.6 | 7:46 | Animal House |
| 319 | 32 | Jon | Ziegler | M | 41 | 3 | M4049 | Warwick | NY | 31:04.0 | 7:46 | |
| 272 | 33 | David | Rivera | M | 31 | 22 | M3039 | Bronx | NY | 31:09.5 | 7:48 | Engine 83 |
| 286 | 34 | Devin | Smith | M | 29 | 6 | M2029 | Suffern | NY | 31:09.8 | 7:48 | E 75 |
| 175 | 35 | Kyle | Best | M | 32 | 23 | M3039 | Medford | NY | 31:12.5 | 7:49 | 42 engine |
| 353 | 36 | Gavin | McArdle | M | 17 | 3 | M1119 | Whitestone | NY | 31:17.0 | 7:50 | M-1 |
| 242 | 37 | Ava | Kelly | F | 14 | 1 | F1119 | Tuckahoe | NY | 31:26.0 | 7:52 | |
| 188 | 38 | Julian | Carney | M | 33 | 24 | M3039 | New York | NY | 31:43.7 | 7:56 | Engine 43 |
| 339 | 39 | Conor | Tierney | M | 26 | 7 | M2029 | Staten Island | NY | 31:47.7 | 7:57 | E28/L11 |
| 308 | 40 | Aidan | Obrien | M | 28 | 8 | M2029 | Bronx | NY | 32:05.5 | 8:02 | 75/33 FDNY |
| 320 | 41 | Zach | Byrne | M | 29 | 9 | M2029 | Bronx | NY | 32:06.0 | 8:02 | Ladder 46 |
| 261 | 42 | Nick | Morisano | M | 33 | 25 | M3039 | Astoria | NY | 32:06.5 | 8:02 | L45 |
| 191 | 43 | Sean | Chick | M | 47 | 4 | M4049 | West Harrison | NY | 32:15.0 | 8:04 | Ladder 44 |
| 169 | 44 | Robenson | Aupont | M | 41 | 5 | M4049 | Bronx | NY | 32:19.7 | 8:05 | Ladder 14 |
| 211 | 45 | Joshua | Faeger | M | 36 | 26 | M3039 | Patchogue | NY | 32:20.7 | 8:06 | FDNY Engine 35 |
| 228 | 46 | Jimmy | Granger | M | 44 | 6 | M4049 | Mountainville | NY | 32:23.6 | 8:06 | FDNY triathlon team-E 312 |
| 172 | 47 | Patrick | Berkey | M | 45 | 7 | M4049 | Floral Park | NY | 32:26.1 | 8:07 | Engine 312 |
| 288 | 48 | Chris | Sweeney | M | 46 | 8 | M4049 | New Windsor | NY | 32:28.1 | 8:07 | Engine 35 |
| 202 | 49 | Kevin | Diercksen | M | 48 | 9 | M4049 | Nanuet | NY | 32:54.8 | 8:14 | FDNY |
| 194 | 50 | Glenn | Coleman | M | 57 | 1 | M5059 | Pearl River | NY | 33:03.1 | 8:16 | |
| 248 | 51 | Dominic | Kulma | M | 31 | 27 | M3039 | Maspeth | NY | 33:30.9 | 8:23 | E312 |
| 362 | 52 | Kasim | Thomas | M | 26 | 10 | M2029 | Bronx | NY | 33:31.0 | 8:23 | Engine 62/Ladder 32 |
| 262 | 53 | Stevenson | Moseley | M | 34 | 28 | M3039 | Astoria | NY | 33:44.8 | 8:27 | Engine 47 |
| 232 | 54 | Patrick | Heffernan | M | 26 | 11 | M2029 | Bronx | NY | 33:46.5 | 8:27 | Ladder 45 |
| 222 | 55 | Brendan | Finnerty | M | 28 | 12 | M2029 | Whitestone | NY | 33:51.6 | 8:28 | FDNY LADDER 29 |
| 201 | 56 | Ramirito | Diaz | M | 36 | 29 | M3039 | Bronx | NY | 33:57.5 | 8:30 | E76/L22 |
| 332 | 57 | Hector | Fernandez | M | 32 | 30 | M3039 | New York | NY | 34:00.7 | 8:31 | E95 L36 |
| 198 | 58 | Chris | Cordova | M | 35 | 31 | M3039 | Mountainville | NY | 34:01.6 | 8:31 | E 312 |
| 216 | 59 | Michael | Fahy | M | 17 | 4 | M1119 | Yonkers | NY | 34:02.4 | 8:31 | Engine 75 / Ladder 33 / Battalion 19 |
| 327 | 60 | Michael | Brogan | M | 32 | 32 | M3039 | Yonkers | NY | 34:05.8 | 8:32 | Animal house // E75 // FDNY |
| 251 | 61 | Daniel | Mansdorf | M | 32 | 33 | M3039 | Hastings On Hud | NY | 34:07.7 | 8:32 | |
| 318 | 62 | Eddie | Reardon | M | 45 | 10 | M4049 | Eastchester | NY | 34:19.6 | 8:35 | FDNY |
| 298 | 63 | Kevin | White | M | 52 | 2 | M5059 | Yorktown Height | NY | 34:21.5 | 8:36 | FDNY |
| 238 | 64 | David | Karikas | M | 29 | 13 | M2029 | Holtsville | NY | 34:36.0 | 8:39 | FDNY Ladder 14 |
| 323 | 65 | Melissa | Burke | F | 31 | 1 | F3039 | Bronx | NY | 34:36.1 | 8:40 | She Runs Empowered |
| 187 | 66 | Michael | Cariello | M | 48 | 11 | M4049 | New York | NY | 34:37.1 | 8:40 | FDNY |
| 364 | 67 | Stephen | Fitzgerald | M | 44 | 12 | M4049 | New York | NY | 34:37.2 | 8:40 | |
| 268 | 68 | Cesar | Pellerano | M | 31 | 34 | M3039 | College Point | NY | 34:49.5 | 8:43 | E93 L45 B13/FDNY |
| 190 | 69 | Joaquin | Castro | M | 43 | 13 | M4049 | Pearl River | NY | 34:52.3 | 8:44 | E93/L45/B13 |
| 306 | 70 | Aidan | Jedlicka | M | 12 | 5 | M1119 | Tuckahoe | NY | 34:53.5 | 8:44 | |
| 195 | 71 | John | Conefrey | M | 13 | 6 | M1119 | Tuckahoe | NY | 34:53.7 | 8:44 | 4 for Fahey |
| 300 | 72 | Joshua | Willis | M | 42 | 14 | M4049 | New York | NY | 34:56.8 | 8:45 | Ladder 29 FDNY |
| 351 | 73 | Cole | Burmester | M | 15 | 7 | M1119 | Whitestone | NY | 35:14.9 | 8:49 | M-1 |
| 231 | 74 | Mark | Hanebury | M | 52 | 3 | M5059 | Levittown | NY | 35:16.3 | 8:50 | Engine 43 |
| 210 | 75 | Alphonso | Espinoza | M | 32 | 35 | M3039 | New York | NY | 35:24.3 | 8:52 | Ladder 36/FDNY |
| 240 | 76 | Brian | ArthuKehoe | M | 22 | 14 | M2029 | Yonkers | NY | 35:26.1 | 8:52 | Ladder 46 |
| 239 | 77 | Brian | Kehoe | M | 45 | 15 | M4049 | Yonkers | NY | 35:26.4 | 8:52 | Ladder 46 |
| 173 | 78 | Nick | Berman | M | 44 | 16 | M4049 | Long Beach | NY | 35:30.7 | 8:53 | 75/33/19 |
| 340 | 79 | Eric | Wendt | M | 45 | 17 | M4049 | Sloatsburg | NY | 35:33.5 | 8:54 | |
| 180 | 80 | Rob | Camaj | M | 35 | 36 | M3039 | North Salem | NY | 35:39.4 | 8:55 | Animal House |
| 199 | 81 | Erick | Costello | M | 41 | 18 | M4049 | Bronx | NY | 35:40.7 | 8:56 | |
| 246 | 82 | Kieran | Kilduff | M | 54 | 4 | M5059 | Tuckahoe | NY | 35:43.0 | 8:56 | B19 |
| 265 | 83 | Daniel | Naranjo | M | 32 | 37 | M3039 | Freeport | NY | 35:46.4 | 8:57 | E83 |
| 263 | 84 | Marissa | Mugno | F | 53 | 2 | F5059 | Tuckahoe | NY | 36:08.3 | 9:03 | 36 truck |
| 303 | 85 | Michael | Wuestenhoef | M | 46 | 19 | M4049 | Bronxville | NY | 36:27.4 | 9:07 | annunciation |
| 316 | 86 | Eddie | Minson | M | 12 | 8 | M1119 | Tuckahoe | NY | 36:28.9 | 9:08 | |
| 311 | 87 | Danny | Elvy | M | 34 | 38 | M3039 | Bronx | NY | 36:44.8 | 9:12 | Ladder 52 |
| 349 | 88 | Lenny | Burmester | M | 49 | 20 | M4049 | Whitestone | NY | 37:05.1 | 9:17 | M-1 |
| 304 | 89 | Daniel | Zayas | M | 27 | 15 | M2029 | Yonkers | NY | 37:19.1 | 9:20 | Engine 35 |
| 277 | 90 | Kevin | Rynne | M | 53 | 5 | M5059 | Briarcliff Mano | NY | 37:30.3 | 9:23 | |
| 370 | 91 | John | Rynne | M | 56 | 6 | M5059 | Bronxville | NY | 37:30.4 | 9:23 | |
| 313 | 92 | Oran | Mahoney | M | 12 | 9 | M1119 | Tuckahoe | NY | 37:32.6 | 9:24 | |
| 276 | 93 | Unknown | Runner | | 0 | 0 | | Unknown | NA | 37:35.2 | 9:24 | |
| 224 | 94 | Ian | Fullam | M | 13 | 10 | M1119 | Yonkers | NY | 37:36.1 | 9:25 | Annunciation School |
| 333 | 95 | Nicholas | Mackenzie | M | 15 | 11 | M1119 | Whitestone | NY | 37:37.9 | 9:25 | |
| 335 | 96 | Andrew | Mackenzie | M | 46 | 21 | M4049 | Whitestone | NY | 37:46.2 | 9:27 | |
| 341 | 97 | Justin | Wendt | M | 16 | 12 | M1119 | Sloatsburg | NY | 37:48.9 | 9:28 | |